Monday, October 24, 2005

No Comment



Torill Mortensen has decided not to have comments on her blog any more.
She wants to see if it makes her blog differently.

This is an interesting idea which I could try. I think I would have started today - if only it had not taken me half an hour on Sunday to work out how to make my 'Comments' section say 'Interjections and Pronouncements' instead.

And then spent a further twenty minutes making the letters fuschia coloured.


Perhaps I am not yet ready for the maturity required to rid myself of comments??

Torill once corrected me on Blogtrax for spelling her name wrongly. That was an interesting thing about identity and reputation I think:

You are on the map as somebody who can’t spell the great Torill Mortensen’s name. You’re in exellent company, but please, pretty please, read my name on my weblog, and get it right?


So it is not at all the case that Torill is uninterested in what others say and do around her work. Maybe she is wanting to think about how her writing will develop without the immediacy of comment reactions and input. But I really like the way my text becomes a new text when others have had their shout. And so as I write here now, I think, that on balance, to remove that affordance, one goes back to writing in a manner which only allows a one directional 'giving voice' - and that is so twentieth century now.

13 comments:

Rob Burton said...

If you wander around the blogoverse aimlessly, one will find tons of blogs that either have their comments off, or simply don't get comments and yet they continue to write.

Human beings have always communicated regardless of the medium. No doubt the individual who drew/wrote pictures on his/her cave wall had particular reasons for doing so.

We all have reasons for blogging. Its a bit like that old saw about why bother learning to be an author because writers write. So writers will write whether or not people comment, or see the writing.

I guess from my perspective, the lucky ones are those who get a wider audience, I welcome comments, I don't get many, but I don't think it affects what I write, I guess I would continue writing weather or not comments happened.

So switching off comments wouldn't affect what I wrote or how I wrote it. All it does I guess is change that individuals relationship with how she thinks, as an intelectual exercise I guess its pretty meaningless.

Kate said...

I htink comments are essential.
I spent one whole eyar being dr Joolz commenter and it was a very comforting role.
However, it has eboldened me to have my own blog now.
However, I think that personally comments are ways of interacting which are very web like and not like books - I would have loved to have commented on some of the books I read or articles I read but I can't be bothered with letters pages and lots of the book people have died.
Hurrah for interjections and other stuff.

Kate said...

By the way I know my spelling is crap but it is hard being both a commenter and a blogger and I can't do both with perfect spelling.

Mary Plain said...

Kate, I agree with you- although I don't get many comments I love it when people do respond. Isn't a blog without comments really just a website that gets updated a lot? whatI enjoy is the way the blog entry sparks a little thread of debate that can go all kinds of places. And Dr Joolz, I love Interjections and Pronouncements! are we still allowed to talk about coats though?

Mary Plain said...

also, I would really miss the word verification game. This time it is guuckpok. Can't get much better..

Joolz said...

It is really interesting about the comments; GUy said he does not mind if he gets comments or not. I know the research sample is miniscule - but is this s gender thing? I love to see what people will say and like to respond.
Do we really believe DrRob and Guy?

Joolz said...

Gosh kate.
You won't get away with that.

I got 'nursie' on my word verification!!

Mary Plain said...

oo er missus!

Guy Merchant said...

no comment

Joolz said...

ha ha ha Guy!!

Anya said...

I tried leaving a comment yesterday to say that I had written some posts about comments too but my comment doesn't appear to haver been processed. Pffft :)

Anya said...

errr... haver = short for 'have ever', or it was a typo... not sure :>

Anonymous said...

Discount RX Pharmacy - Cialis, Viagra, Levitra, Tamiflu. Get Cheap Medication online. Buy Pills Central.
[url=http://buypillscentral.com/about_en-us.htm]Discount Viagra, Cialis, Levitra, Tamiflu Drugstore without prescription[/url]. prescription generic pills. Cheap drugs pharmacy

Powered By Blogger

About Me

My photo
Sheffield, South Yorks, United Kingdom
I am an academic interested in New Literacies, Digital Lifestyles, Informal Online Learning.